Auditions: The Best Christmas Pageant Ever
Loading Events

« All Events

  • This event has passed.

Auditions: The Best Christmas Pageant Ever

September 27, 2023 @ 7:00 pm - 9:00 pm

Event Series Event Series (See All)

Mary Robinson’s The Best Christmas Pageant Ever, based on her novel of the same name, is a widely beloved Christmas tale, warm and incredibly funny, full of characters both relatable and utterly unique.

The large cast and age range make this show a community favorite, in which a varied, multi-generational group of performers can come together.


Auditions for The Best Christmas Pageant Ever, directed by Francesca Stokes and stage managed by Bernadette Oberndorf will be held as follows:

Audition Date & Times:

  • Tuesday Sept 26th  from 7pm to 9pm
  • Wednesday Sept 27 from 7 pm to 9 pm
  • Callbacks (if needed) will be Thursday Sept 28th from 7pm to 9 pm (by invitation only)
  • If unable to attend in person, you can submit a video audition via YouTube and completed audition form and conflicts calendar to by Sep 25th

Location: 15 Frank E. Rodgers Blvd. South, Harrison, NJ (the former Holy Cross High School)

Production Dates: Dec 1st – Dec 10th

All actors of any background in Grade 2 and older are invited to audition

Actors under 18 must be accompanied by a parent/guardian at all times during auditions



* Read Thru – Saturday, October 14th at 2:00 pm

Rehearsals will take place on weekday evenings and possibly an afternoon on the weekends. 

Actors should have good availability the two weeks prior to the show (excluding Thanksgiving Day, Nov 23rd).

Please list all conflicts between October 14th and the shows on the Conflicts Calendar Form. 


The original production of The Best Christmas Pageant Ever cast 19 actors, with ages ranging from 7 to 60+. Please be honest on your audition form about the roles you would accept. 


All actors should have strong comedic timing. 



Beth Bradley’s church’s Christmas pageant is predictable every year — the angel choir sings off key, the shepherds are all in their father’s bathrobes, the minister’s son is permanently cast in the role of Joseph. It is hardly “four-star entertainment.” But when seasoned and authoritative pageant director Mrs. Armstrong breaks her leg, it is up to Beth’s inexperienced mother Grace to step in. The timing couldn’t be worse, as the rambunctious Herdman children, a rough and tough group of siblings, descend upon the pageant, lured by the promise of free dessert at Sunday school, and determined to win all the lead roles for themselves. The Ladies’ Aid Society members are beside themselves with disapproval, all the shepherds quit because Gladys Herdman “hits too hard”, the show is briefly re-titled “Revenge at Bethlehem,” and the church catches on fire. But Beth and her community watch in surprise as the same old Christmas story is rejuvenated by the creativity, energy, and unexpected sincerity of a misunderstood young family.



Cast size of 20 people, 2nd grade and older.


Mother (Grace Bradley)  (female) – age 35-45 attractive, involved mom 

Father (Bob Bradley) (male) – age 35-45 solid, family man 

Beth Bradley (female) – Age 10-11 the narrator, strong voice and presence

Charlie Bradley (male) – Age 8-9 traditional kid brother

Ralph Herdman (male) – Age 12-13 ragged, scroungy, slouching manner; touch of adolescent cool

Imogene Herdman (female) – Age 11-12 loud, bossy, crafty

Leroy Herdman (male) – Age 10-11 tough, sure of himself

Claude Herdman (male) – Age 9-10 tough, combative

Ollie Herdman (male) – Age 8-9 looking for trouble, Claude’s usual partner in crime

Gladys Herdman (female) – Age 7-8 small, wiry, feisty 

Alice Wendleken (female) Age 10-11 prim, proper, pain in the neck 

Mrs. Armstrong (female) – Age 45-60 managerial in voice and manner 

Mrs. Slocum (female) – Age 35-60 pleasant, motherly woman

Mrs. Clark (female) – Age 35-60

Mrs. Clausing (female) – Age 35-60

Mrs. McCarthy (female) – Age 40-55 a younger, less imperial version of Mrs. Armstrong

Maxine (female) – Age 10-11

Elmer Hopkins (male) – Age 12-13

Hobie (male) – Age 9-10

David (male) – Age 8-9

Beverly (female) – Age 7-8

Shirley (female) – Age 5-6

Juanita (female) – Age 5-6

Doris (female) – Age 9-10

Reverend Hopkins (male) – Age mid-40’s


Actors will be asked to read from the scenes in the Audition Packet during the auditions.



September 27, 2023
7:00 pm - 9:00 pm
Event Categories:
, ,


Holy Cross School
15 Frank E. Rodgers Boulevard South
Harrison, 07029 United States
+ Google Map
View Venue Website

Start typing and press Enter to search

Shopping Cart